When Can You Discontinue an Action in Ontario?

When a plaintiff wants to discontinue an action against a defendant before the close of pleadings in Ontario, they have the right to do so by serving a Notice of Discontinuance on all parties served with a statement of claim and filing the notice with proof of service in the registrar’s office.

How to Discontinue an Action Before the Close of Pleadings

When a plaintiff wants to discontinue an action against a defendant before the close of pleadings in Ontario, they have the right to do so by serving a Notice of Discontinuance on all parties served with a statement of claim and filing the notice with proof of service in the registrar’s office. Rule 25.05 governs the close of pleadings and provides that pleadings are closed when the plaintiff has delivered a reply to every defence in the action or the time for delivery of a reply has expired, and every defendant who is in default in delivering a defence in the action has been noted in default. It’s worth noting that if a defendant has not been served with a statement of claim, the plaintiff isn’t required to serve the notice of discontinuance on that defendant. Neither a party nor the court can compel another party to discontinue an action, and so long as the limitation period has not expired and nothing else bars it, the plaintiff can commence a further action.

How to Discontinue an Action After the Close of Pleadings

The ability of a plaintiff to discontinue an action without leave of the court is limited to a certain stage in the proceedings, after which the court must consider all relevant circumstances in deciding whether or not to grant leave to discontinue. The court must balance and weigh the rights and interests of both parties, taking into account the potential prejudice to each party. Prejudice may include the loss of evidence or witnesses, the denial of a trial, and the potential for further litigation. If the court decides to grant leave to discontinue, it may impose terms to address any prejudice to the defendant. The court may also refuse leave to discontinue if there is a concern of abuse or substantial prejudice to the defendant, which would require compelling evidence from the opposing party. If a plaintiff seeks to discontinue an action for the purpose of circumventing an interim order or to evade the effect of an order, it may be considered an abuse of process. In such cases, the plaintiff may be required to provide an undertaking not to bring any further actions for the same cause of action. The firm advises on discontinuance, and on the costs that follow it, as part of its civil litigation practice in Toronto.

For a discontinuance of your own, the intake form is the way to reach the firm.

This article is part of the firm’s work in civil litigation.

Share
Start your file

Where the article ends and your matter begins.

Grigoras Law acts for businesses and individuals across Ontario in civil and commercial litigation, arbitration, regulatory proceedings, transactions and corporate matters. New matters begin with the intake form. The firm reads every submission, and where the matter is one it can take, a lawyer replies within two (2) business days with the next step.

Response: within two (2) business days of an intake the firm can take on Advice: the firm advises only its clients; an article or an intake form does not retain it